-
Image:Freelbeforedrunkdriving.jpg (
delete |
talk |
history |
logs) - uploaded by
Stopprop (
notify |
contribs).
- Claims public domain, but no information on photographer given. Also, given the filename this might be intended as an attack on the subject, who was indeed charged with drunk driving. While that fact is relevant to the article, I don't know that including an image about it is really appropriate.
W.marsh
23:23, 20 August 2007 (UTC)
reply
- Public domain because photographer was a private citizen who happened across Freel at the bar (my friend). The photographer was asked kindly to take the photo and complied, however keeping a copy for himself. Maybe the photo should be retitled because it could be possibly libelous. Also I think that Freel's wikipedia page should be re-done to the outline of other baseball players example:
Cole Hamels.
stopprop 20:50, 20 August 2007
- Image deleted. The image cannot be claimed to be in the public domain without a release from the photographer. -
Nv8200p
talk
00:26, 29 August 2007 (UTC)
reply
-
Image:Z!D 07.jpg (
delete |
talk |
history |
logs) - uploaded by
Zahid89 (
notify |
contribs).
-
Image:L 61a5afd6db9715166631f9959a6ee2ab.gif (
delete |
talk |
history |
logs) - uploaded by
Rap dogg89 (
notify |
contribs).
-
Image:Angry.JPG (
delete |
talk |
history |
logs) - uploaded by
Screech123 (
notify |
contribs).
-
Image:FYSIWALOL by jujimufu.gif (
delete |
talk |
history |
logs) - uploaded by
Jujimufu (
notify |
contribs).
-
Image:Hatespeech.jpg (
delete |
talk |
history |
logs) - uploaded by
Sugplumxx (
notify |
contribs).
-
Image:Helicopter.jpg (
delete |
talk |
history |
logs) - uploaded by
Helicopter59 (
notify |
contribs).
- Orphaned, and there's no real place to use it, anyway. There's no indication as to what kind of helicopter it is, so it can't be used for illustration that way, and the girl in front of the chopper doesn't make it a very good choice.
fuzzy510
05:03, 20 August 2007 (UTC)
reply
Isnt even linked into any articles. Should be erased for sure, plus i doubt the girl's parents would want that picture on wikipedia, since she is obviously underage. --
Stopprop
00:57, 21 August 2007 (UTC)
reply
-
Image:High contrastcopyright.png (
delete |
talk |
history |
logs) - uploaded by
Geni (
notify |
contribs).
-
Image:Hélou.jpg (
delete |
talk |
history |
logs) - uploaded by
Davidcannon (
notify |
contribs).
- Lebanese copyright on photos expires 50 years after production - if it's from '56 or earlier it'd be copyrighted, but given when he was president, it seems more likely it was produced in the 1960s - anyone have any insight? Think he might be 43 or younger in that photo?
Wily
D
13:57, 20 August 2007 (UTC)
reply
-
Image:Collegeofsocialstudies.jpg (
delete |
talk |
history |
logs) - uploaded by
Jdwatson (
notify |
contribs).
-
Image:DAT.JPG (
delete |
talk |
history |
logs) - uploaded by [[User talk:#Image:DAT.JPG listed for deletion|]] ([ notify] |
contribs).
-
Image:Big font debug screenshot.png (
delete |
talk |
history |
logs) - uploaded by
Titoxd (
notify |
contribs).
-
Image:AGP keys diagram.png (
delete |
talk |
history |
logs) - uploaded by
Windkin (
notify |
contribs).
-
Image:Goku HighRes.png (
delete |
talk |
history |
logs) - uploaded by
UzEE (
notify |
contribs).
- Copyright violation, derivative work. User copied a copyrighted character from a manga/anime series and claimed the image as their own against all existing copyright laws.-
Kariteh
13:00, 20 August 2007 (UTC)
reply
- All I would like to say is that I made the Image myself. Its not copied. I can provide the source files.
UzEE (
Talk •
Contribs)
19:26, 20 August 2007 (UTC)
reply
- I meant "copied" in the sense that it's a copyrighted character. The rights of the owner (Toriyama, Toei Animation or whoever) still apply whether you take a screenshot, a photo, or even when you redraw the character; the rights are not just on the media but also on the design itself.
Kariteh
21:25, 20 August 2007 (UTC)
reply
- So is there any way it can be improved? I mean a Fair-Use Rationale?
UzEE (
Talk •
Contribs)
05:34, 21 August 2007 (UTC)
reply
- I don't think there's really a way. It would actually be better (and more precise from an encyclopedic viewpoint) to use an original copyrighted image than to create a derivative work (see
Squall Leonhart maybe for a good example). The only instances where derivative works are (more or less) accepted is when the design is very generic, like with the mushroom icon that the WikiProject Nintendo uses.
Kariteh
08:35, 21 August 2007 (UTC)
reply
-
Image:Xia class submarine.jpg (
delete |
talk |
history |
logs) - uploaded by
Dziban303 (
notify |
contribs).
-
Image:Jin class.jpg (
delete |
talk |
history |
logs) - uploaded by
Hallo84 (
notify |
contribs).
- Fair use rationale is not nearly detailed enough for Wikipedia's purposes. Source is not accessible, as requires registration and appears to be a forum so is not reliable enough to verify this is the submarine in question - could be a fake. Also is not historic at all - looks fairly recent.
John Smith's
14:59, 20 August 2007 (UTC)
reply
-
Image:Jl1.jpg (
delete |
talk |
history |
logs) - uploaded by
Hallo84 (
notify |
contribs).
- Fair use rationale is not nearly detailed enough for Wikipedia's purposes. Source is not accessible, as requires registration and appears to be a forum so is not reliable enough to verify the content. Also is not historic at all - looks fairly recent.
John Smith's
15:08, 20 August 2007 (UTC)
reply
-
Image:JL2.jpg (
delete |
talk |
history |
logs) - uploaded by
Hallo84 (
notify |
contribs).
- Fair use rationale is not nearly detailed enough for Wikipedia's purposes. Source is not accessible, as requires registration and appears to be a forum so is not reliable enough to verify the content. Also is not historic at all - looks fairly recent.
John Smith's
15:08, 20 August 2007 (UTC)
reply
-
Image:Weston_city_of_toronto_113.jpg (
delete |
talk |
history |
logs) - uploaded by
Weston ontario (
notify |
contribs).
-
Image:Kansas House of Representatives.jpg (
delete |
talk |
history |
logs) - uploaded by
Miles530 (
notify |
contribs).
- Unless the person who posted this picture defends his post, it should be deleted.
--
Stopprop
00:59, 21 August 2007 (UTC)
reply
-
Image:Lol odex.jpg (
delete |
talk |
history |
logs) - uploaded by
Question2 (
notify |
contribs).
- As a passerby with no strong feelings about this Odex debacle, I've nonetheless noted that
Tueac seems to have a pro-Odex inclination on
Talk:Odex and elsewhere, and am inclined to take his claims with a grain of salt. I'd really like to see solid proof from either side that this image is or is not what it claims to be, such as an official list of Odex releases or a photo of the VCD cover; I was unable to locate such proof myself using Google. If the standard Wikipedia protocol is to automatically delete a suspicious image like this, though, I have no complaints. -
Seventh Holy Scripture
05:29, 21 August 2007 (UTC)
reply
- I'm not Odex inclined but just want the correct information to be present. about the proof of Poh kim being the sole distro of Initial D, here
[1] Although this is the Stage 4 rather than the stage 2 and not the VCD cover but there are other example of Poh kim' earlier covers like this
[2] with a Poh Kim Logo on the top left side. Other than that and the Odex logo on the back, they almost have the same cover... when compared to this
[3]Note: Last picture taken at a Poh kim retail store with Poh kim price tag...
Tueac
07:41, 21 August 2007 (UTC)
reply
-
Image:Tv_guide_50_greatest.jpg (
delete |
talk |
history |
logs) - uploaded by
Zanimum (
notify |
contribs).
- Query Er...given that judgment of NFCC#8 is entirely subjective, how can any supposed violation of it be "patent"? Maybe a delete argument longer than three words would help clarify your position.—
DCGeist
06:14, 26 August 2007 (UTC)
reply
-
Image:Heinlein-Number-of-the-Beast.jpg (
delete |
talk |
history |
logs) - uploaded by
Bogdangiusca (
notify |
contribs).
- *The three sentences: "
Robert A. Heinlein, in
The Number of the Beast, postulated a six-dimensional universe. In addition to the three spatial dimensions, he invoked
symmetry to add two new temporal dimensions, so there would be two sets of three. Like the fourth dimension of H. G. Wells’
time traveler, these extra dimensions can be traveled by persons using the right equipment."
-
Image:DailyShowClinton.jpg (
delete |
talk |
history |
logs) - uploaded by
Tertiary7 (
notify |
contribs).
- Primary reason: the image doesn't significantly increase readers' understanding of the topic of the article (fails
WP:NFCC #8). In the article
Bill Clinton it is used as decoration, the television program is not critically discussed or even mentioned in the text. In the article
The Daily Show it is used as decoration, the interview is not critically discussed in the text. Secundary reason: no unique fair use rationale with clear purpose of use description for each use of the image.
Ilse
@
20:21, 20 August 2007 (UTC)
reply
- Some
comments to the nomination. –
Ilse
@
07:41, 22 August 2007 (UTC)
reply
- Keep per action taken I have moved the image in the article on
The Daily Show to a more appropriate position, expanded the caption to show exactly when this interview took place, and greatly expanded the discussion of the interview in the article to show the significance of the event illustrated by this image. I have also revised and expanded the fair use rationale to make clear its purpose on
The Daily Show (not sure how to deal with syntax of this rationale box to alter box header, but specificity of rationale is clear in box's main text).—
DCGeist
18:00, 26 August 2007 (UTC)
reply
- The image does not contain any significant information that is not already in the text, it is merely decoration (fails
WP:NFCC #8). –
Ilse
@
07:16, 27 August 2007 (UTC)
reply
- Keep per
DCGeist action- thank you
Astuishin (
talk)
18:31, 28 August 2007 (UTC)
reply
- Image deleted. Image was of no significance to the article and merely decorative. Fails
WP:NFCC #8. -
Nv8200p
talk
00:36, 29 August 2007 (UTC)
reply
-
Image:Csu_poster.jpg (
delete |
talk |
history |
logs) - uploaded by
Acne m (
notify |
contribs).
-
Image:Cubby_cropp.jpg (
delete |
talk |
history |
logs) - uploaded by
Machocarioca (
notify |
contribs).
-
Image:Gwen-Stefani-4-In-The-Morning-407004.jpg (
delete |
talk |
history |
logs) - uploaded by
Explode24 (
notify |
contribs).