I am restarting this nomination because the last one went on for too long; it was on hold while Half-Life 2 was at FAR (which it passed), and there was a dispute regarding this topic's name. Let's start this from scratch, shall we? GaryKing (
talk)19:08, 15 October 2008 (UTC)reply
Support under this name or "Half-Life 2 episodes", but not under "Half-Life 2 titles" or "Half-Life 2 episodes". Beyond that, open to further suggestions -
rst20xx (
talk)
23:42, 15 October 2008 (UTC)reply
Additional comment - as per Rreagan007's penultimate comment on the previous nomination, I would prefer to see a general "Half-Life 2 titles" topic, that also includes
Half-Life 2: Lost Coast and
Half-Life 2: Survivor. However, I feel that this just about passes the "does not overly overlap" and cherrypicking rules as is, without them -
rst20xx (
talk)
23:47, 15 October 2008 (UTC)reply
I still believe it would be more prudent to work towards a full Half-Life series topic (not focusing exclusively on HL2 titles, but including
HL1, its expansions and the
series article), but as long as that can be addressed through supplemental nominations later, I guess I can support. --
Sabre (
talk)
11:17, 16 October 2008 (UTC)reply
Oppose. I've had a lot of time to think about this one, and the more I think about it the less I like it. I'm sure everyone here would agree that it would be much better if this could be a larger "Half-Life 2" or even "Half-Life" topic. Unfortunately, those topics aren't ready yet. If it weren't for the large degree of overlap with The Orange Box topic I probably would have supported anyway, but the overlap pushes me over the edge to oppose. Sorry guys.
Rreagan007 (
talk)
14:57, 16 October 2008 (UTC)reply
Oppose I once thought that while there was a lot of overlap orange box was a totally different ball game, but with the only new article being an audited article, I see no reason to promote until episode three is released or more artilces are added. Sorry.
Zginder 2008-10-16T15:06Z (
UTC)
To clarify, I would support this when either three is promoted or other artilces that would not create a gap are added.
Zginder 2008-10-18T01:07Z (
UTC)