After a bit of work, I am finally ready to introduce to you the first GTC from the
North Indian Ocean basin; basically it is anywhere in the Indian Ocean north of the Equator. This GTC contains of three good articles, two of which passed in the last 7 months and the other was restored not too long ago to reflect more recent GA standards. If you were gonna ask if other storms need an article, the answer to that question is no. Anyway, hope you enjoy this collection of articles! --
12george1 (
talk)
19:40, 14 November 2013 (UTC)reply
After being asked to comment here by
Hurricanehink I thought i would take a look over the articles before i support them.
Too start with i spotted that "Cyclone 02B co-existed in a pair, with the southern counterpart being Tropical Cyclone Errol, which was in the South Indian Ocean within Tropical Cyclone Warning Centre (TCWC) Jakarta's area of responsibility." - Except it wasn't since the Indonesian Met was not a TCWC until 2007-08.
I also noticed that you dont use the
IMD journal report or the
best track in any of the articles, which might help expand the details on the article. I also notice from the BT that the Depressions were was BoB 02.
I think you need to do some more research on the systems numbering - i dont know which is more reliable Gary Padgetts summaries or the IMD BT, but the IMD have labelled each system they monitored BOB or ARB XX within their BT.
The 2002 North Indian Ocean cyclone season was a below active season in terms of tropical cyclone formation - Add to the SS and source please, as im fairly sure that 4 CS is not below average.
What is this relaible source and what is it saying? - My
reliable source (The IMD) says 5.4 CSand 2.5 SCS is the average for a season. Which would place this season as average imo since we have to allow for some flexability on the numbers.
Jason Rees (
talk)
19:34, 7 January 2014 (UTC)reply
The season has no official bounds, but cyclones tend to form between April and December. - change to past tense and maybe add a line about the monsoon season.
With seven depressions and four cyclonic storms, this was one of the least active season in the ocean on record - i cant say im happy about the fact being presented here.
2002 Oman Cyclone is calling out for more research into its impact and aftermath - try digging around some government websites for this.
I'm not sure what you're looking for, but I really can't find more information. Even though 2002 wasn't all that long ago, for whatever reason, there is little info on this storm, aside from historical notes that its landfall is fairly rare. --♫
Hurricanehink (
talk)
16:22, 23 December 2013 (UTC)reply
For any references to IBTRACS please make sure that you are using their full names and have the names in the same format.
On West Bengal - please check the BT and combine this sentence into one. "Around 0300 UTC on November 10, a depression developed in the southwestern Bay of Bengal.[1] Three hours later, a bulletin from the India Meteorological Department (IMD) indicated that BOB 01 formed about 265 km (165 mi) east-southeast of Chennai, India."
This nomination has been up for over two months. Is Jason planning on adding more later or will he be able to decide on whether to Support or Oppose the nomination?
GamerPro6419:04, 21 January 2014 (UTC)reply
Just so you guys know, I am still planning on finish. The remaining issues seem to be with the BTs and the numbering of the TCs. Unfortunately, I do not have time to fix this right now. I am leaving soon and won't be home until about 8 hours later.--
12george1 (
talk)
17:19, 22 January 2014 (UTC)reply
With over three months open and the lack of supports or any new constructive comments for over a month, I am Closing this nomination with no consensus to promote. Another review can be opened anytime. Hopefully the next one can go by more smoothly.
GamerPro6417:54, 17 February 2014 (UTC)reply