The result was delete. — Coffee // have a cup // essay // 03:25, 11 March 2011 (UTC) reply
Fails our criteria for notability. This is part of a long-standing dispute over the work of Christian O'Brien who is notable because of his work as Chairman and General Manager of the Anglo-Iranian Oil Company (now BP} but was also a minor fringe writer whose fringe writings now dominate his biography and have been and in this case are being promoted through Wikipedia. Dougweller ( talk) 05:55, 1 March 2011 (UTC) reply
Keep This early section of O'Brien's work has had peer review and was featured in The Sunday Telegraph Magazine in March 1978 and also the Fortean Times 2006. I'd consider it meets criteria for notability with these sources. The remains of the Loxodrome are also part of the landscape, so should not be deleted so easily. They are there and I've tried to give this article and unbiased approach with the academic comments available, not really promoting anymore. Paul Bedson ( talk) 08:58, 1 March 2011 (UTC) reply
I'm happy to rename and revise this to accomodate a substantial extra source in the Newman/Darvil book and better naming convention. The more hill figures, the merrier the enigma. I want to get this correct though and I can see all sorts of problems, from the fact that I am not quite sure whether the loxodrome line actually hits Portingbury Hills but through what O'Brien called Portingbury Warren Circle, which I think the sources may be referring to as another circle coming out of the lake nearby in Hatfield Forest. I'm not really sure about this and am going to have to go there sometime in the Summer to figure out which enlosure links to which zig-zag bank. The problem seems to have been caused by the Wikipedia page about Little Hallingbury (NOT created by me!) being a direct copyvio transcription from David Hoppit's "Wandlebury Enigma" Sunday Telegraph Article!!! Some resident from Little Hallingbury perhaps has considered my source substantial enough it would seem to directly quote the existence of their village by it. I'll agree to tidy that page up to sweeten the deal. Paul Bedson ( talk) 04:34, 5 March 2011 (UTC) reply