The result was keep. -Scottywong | verbalize _ 23:12, 14 June 2012 (UTC) reply
I believe that the article
Rania Khan does not meet the
Wikipedia:Notability criteria to justify a separate entry. I believe this article fails on a number of grounds. The creator of the article is
User:Tanbircdq who has only ever made one entry - this one. I believe this is an example of
sock puppetry and the actual author is the subject of the article. Either that, or the creator is a close associate of the subject. Therefore, this article is a
prima facie example of self promotion. Furthermore, most of the sources cited in the article are minor references in political websites or articles where she receives a mention in trivial media. There are also one or two pieces she has written herself. Again this fails the notability criteria. A person independent of this topic would not consider her notable enough - or if she was - then every local councillor or occasional journalist deserves their own page.
This article also fails for not providing Neutral sources as self-published sources cannot be assumed neutral and the piece is entirely uncritical. Aetheling1125 — Preceding
unsigned comment added by
Aetheling1125 (
talk •
contribs)