The result was delete. With salt. The Bushranger One ping only 03:27, 4 November 2017 (UTC)
The article is a recreation under deliberately misspelled title of
Nicholas Alahverdian which has been created and deleted on 18 August 2013 following
deletion discussion, which was later re-created, G4’d and salted on 29 August 2013 with a reinforcement of the salting on 13 February 2015.
Similarly, under
Nicholas Edward Alahverdian, creation, deletion and salting in February 2015. Similar salting circumvention attempt with another misspelled article under
Nicolas Alaverdian.
Authors repeatedly removed CSD tags under IP addresses which I assume linked to the main author, preventing admin review of the CSD. Sockpuppet investigations have not been opened at the time, however there is indication given the IP address originated from
Providence, RI and it may be autobiographic. Only meaningful
contributor appears to be a
single purpose account
One of the key claims for notability for the subject is the case of Alahverdian v. Rhode Island Department of Children, Youth and Families. This has also been subject of another AfD on 18 August 2013 with the result
delete.
Beyond this, notability is claimed to be established as member of the Rhode Island Future PAC, one of
several thousand PACs in the US. Google searches
here and
here do not make this PAC notable, other than its existence in PAC registers. Besides, as per
WP:INHERITED, notability of the PAC (which is not given), does not created notability of people connected with it.
Commentary on individual references in the article
1,2,10,11,13,16,21,24,25,26,34,36 – relate to original 2012 lawsuit, previously deemend insufficient for notability or
WP:BLP1E
5 - self published
3,4 – PAC/Lobbyist registration related. Proving the fact, but not notability
6 – mention in passing as campaign manager for
Brian Coogan (politician)
7 – IMDd not sufficient for notability
8,12,20,22,28,32,33 – dead/404/page time out
9,19,30 – login required for a database (
WP:PAYWALL)
14,37 – text of bill passed re. RI Department of CYF. No immediate evidence for individual notability
15,18 – mention in passing in relation to above bill and his court case
17,23,31 – unrelated/no mention at all
Therefore, the article likely falls under
WP:BLP1E and lacks
individual notability. Coverage is primarily in local media, therefore may fail
depth of coverage and is (with few exceptions) not
persistent. Google searches indicate significant tapering off in terms of coverage from 2015 onwards.pseudonym
Jake Brockman
talk 08:42, 21 October 2017 (UTC)