The result was - Keep - non-admin closure - Peripitus (Talk) 12:07, 18 July 2008 (UTC) reply
Previously nominated in April. Passed per WP:CLN, i.e. a list may be developed further than a category. However, since then, no changes have been made except new bare list entries. A quick glance reveals REO Speedwagon and Therapy?, definitively not hard rock bands. Category:hard rock groups is appropriate in part because the auto-link from each article (or conspicuous lack thereof) helps filter and develop the proper list. Here however we see a tendency to wp:listcruft with little prospect and no progress of comprehensively adding cross-reference information, blurbs, or such.
Article may be recreated without prejudice after deletion by copying category contents. So long as intent is to add value. Potatoswatter ( talk) 13:59, 6 July 2008 (UTC) reply
The problem is that this includes nearly all rock that isn't "pop" and then some that is: distorted guitar is mighty popular. Meanwhile musicians are virtually guaranteed to fall into another list, such as List of heavy metal bands—an exemplary list. Are there some bands best typified as hard rock? Sure... Deep Purple, Blue Oyster Cult. Do Boston and David Bowie also belong? Well, technically. But tell a record store clerk you like hard rock such as Pat Benatar, and the guitar distortion will be curtailed. And don't get me started on Bijelo Dugme.Hard rock is a variation of rock music which has its earliest roots in mid-1960s garage and psychedelic rock. It is typified by a heavy use of distorted electric guitars, bass guitar, keyboards and drums. The term "hard rock" is often used as an umbrella term for genres such as Alternative, Grunge, heavy metal and Punk in order to distinguish them from pop rock.
- Peripitus (Talk) 12:07, 18 July 2008 (UTC) reply