The result was delete all except for Ghar-e Rubah Minining Complex, Iran Engineerging Company, Iran Rubberworks, Qazvin-Rasht Road Construction Company, Unity Cooperative Company and Ziaran Meat Packing Company deleted via PROD and Defense Industry Complex, Isfahan and Natanz Steel Plant removed from nomination list and Nuclear Power Plant, Bushehr turned into a redirect. Liz Read! Talk! 17:36, 8 August 2022 (UTC)
[Hide this box] New to Articles for deletion (AfD)? Read these primers!
Mass-created article made in violation of
WP:MASSCREATE/
WP:MEATBOT based on the 2006 Iranian census, see
Wikipedia:Arbitration/Requests/Case/Carlossuarez46 for all the gory details. The Iranian census gathered data by whatever the closest named landmark was, including pumps, factories, farms, bridges, individual houses and so-forth. Carlossuarez46 apparently realised that something was wrong in this case based on the name, but decided that this (and every other case like it) was really a "company town" despite no source actually saying so. As such this fails
WP:GEOLAND#1 since it is not really a legally-recognised populated place, but instead a factory of some kind that census-takers have used as a reference point. The real standard that should be applied here is
WP:CORP as it is a company/organisation of some kind. This article obviously fails that standard, as there is no evidence even of a
WP:GNG pass much less the kind of coverage needed to pass
WP:AUD/
WP:CORPDEPTH.
Together with this article I am also nominating the articles on the following list, all of which appear to have been hoax/spam articles created by Carlossuarez46 using the same template and sourcing, and which Carlos also added to the "Company towns in Iran" category. As such bundling is justified per
WP:BUNDLE. In all cases, the appropriate standard is
WP:CORP since they are really companies/institutions and they fail that standard.
Coverage in Wiki-like sources like Citypedia.ir, Tageo, Geonames or similar sources does not remedy this issue as they are unreliable. GEOnet Names Server is also unreliable for the purpose of establishing a
WP:GEOLAND#1 pass
per the RSN discussion. Similarly, use of company/institutional websites cannot sustain a
WP:CORP pass, nor can coverage in local press, or
WP:MILL coverage. Some of the articles are accompanied by co-ordinates but it is not clear where these co-ordinates were obtained from and they often do not point to a site that is built on, but even when they do it is impossible to know what they point to without engaging in
WP:OR. Even if the co-ordinates do indicate a village, it is impossible to know whether the village is known by the name in the article.
The only exception are articles like Nuclear Power Plant, Bushehr which are about very notable topics . . . which are already covered entirely by other articles (e.g., Bushehr Nuclear Power Plant).
(PS - these will all be templated with AWB soon) FOARP ( talk) 18:17, 1 August 2022 (UTC)