Hi there! Thank you for your patience. I'm going to be reviewing this GAN. Any section marked with a Working tag means I haven't finished making comments there, but feel free to start addressing my comments before I'm finished! Kncny11(shoot)22:18, 6 March 2021 (UTC)reply
Note: this represents where the article stands relative to the
Good Article criteria. Criteria marked are unassessed
Infobox and lede
Working
Early years
This section is usually titled "Early life."
At no point does reference [3] mention that Alibay Jr. was a baseball player. This needs a citation.
Do we know why he changed his commitment?
The information about his parents, siblings, and uncle should all be condensed here instead of split between here and the personal life section later on.
Article appears relatively stable. 3 reverts in the past month.
Photos are all free use and relevant.
Career awards and records should be in their own section between stats and personal life. See GAs
Mark Sanchez and
Peyton Manning for examples.
Final comments and verdict
After finishing the section on his college career, it became obvious that I'm going to have to quick-fail this article. Multiple statements that need citations don't have them, or the attached reference doesn't actually mention what the article suggests that it does, or the reference is unreliable. To my chagrin, I'm going to have to ✗ Fail this article for the time being, and politely ask the nominator to focus their efforts on finding reliable sources that mention all of the information in the article before bringing it back to GAN. Kncny11(shoot)22:59, 6 March 2021 (UTC)reply