Hello, I recently closed the AfD discussion for this article, where several editors opined that a merge would be a good idea. I do not have much knowledge or interest in this topic, but I think a merge sounds like a pretty good idea. Anyone have any suggestions or concerns? If nobody objects, I think it should be relatively noncontroversial for any interested editor(s) to begin merging the content, as long as the edit summary gives credit to this article for proper GFDL attribution. Something like "Merging content from
List of Elite Four members" would do. If you want to talk to me about something related to this merge proposal or this article, please let me know on my talk page, as I am not watching this article or talk page. Thanks, Jerrydelusional ¤
kangaroo22:27, 8 September 2008 (UTC)reply
As the nominator of the AFD, I supported a merge as a reasonable compromise. I'd just like to voice my support for it, since this article doesn't meet its
WP:N requirements otherwise. (Unless someone finds appropriate sources that are both reliable and independent of Pokemon.)
Randomran (
talk)
22:48, 8 September 2008 (UTC)reply
Should clearly be merged - that was the clear consensus at the AfD. Surprised this is still here. I think AmiB clearly demonstrated the issues with sourcing.
Eusebeus (
talk)
12:16, 10 September 2008 (UTC)reply
Gothic Lolita
Resolved
I'm guessing we just call Cythia's clothing gothic lolita, since thats what it most appears. It is not lingerie and the old comment was biased.
Should we include Drake of the orange island since you need all the badge to battle him and he does not gives any badges, he is somehow like the champion of the region.
Ragnaroknike14:08, 14 October 2006 (UTC)reply
The table of contents is reacting in a poor fashion with Lorelei's infobox, leaving a big white gap in the page. Anyone know how to rid the article of this atrocity? --
Brandon Dilbeck08:19, 7 January 2007 (UTC)reply
Okay, there. Someone had the bright idea of putting the contents on the RIGHT side...should obviously be on the left. I also made the contents less...exhaustive...it's just the characters there now.—
ウルタプ18:59, 7 January 2007 (UTC)reply
Game Guide
Resolved
In the section for Arron it mentions that it would be "hard" to beat him without status healing items, I object to that for two reasons.
1. It is gameguide-ish info.
2. It is inaccurate, I crushed him with brute force, using no item to get over the status effects, I crushed him on my first leauge challenge.
BassxForte01:16, 28 June 2007 (UTC)reply
Kill it. I haven't read this article in a good long while, and was pretty horrified at all the game guidish material that it contained.
hbdragon8822:28, 17 September 2007 (UTC)reply
Pictures
Resolved
Maybe it's just my horrible computer failing to load them, but I don't think there's pictures on this page, which there should be. They're available all over the internet--we just have to find ones that don't infringe on any legal matters.
24.15.53.225 (
talk)
03:51, 2 August 2008 (UTC)reply
That would actually likely be impossible. Any and all pictures of these fictional characters would be copyrighted works. Except pictures of people in halloween costumes or holding stuffed animal things, which would probably not help the article at all. The only other choice would be Fair Use pictures, which is rather dodgy, unless the article itself goes into essential description of the character's appearance, and a picture is required to make this explanation understandable. Jerrydelusional ¤
kangaroo00:06, 9 September 2008 (UTC)reply