Home
•
Search
•
Translate
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
<
Talk:Civil Air Patrol
GA Review
GA
review
(see
here
for criteria)
It is
reasonably well written
.
a
(prose)
:
b
(
MoS
)
:
I fixed a few acronym inconsistencies, and tagged an unclear statement.
It is
factually accurate
and
verifiable
.
a
(references)
:
b
(citations to
reliable sources
)
:
c
(
OR
)
:
I left one citation tag for a paragraph that wasn't cited at all.
It is
broad in its coverage
.
a
(major aspects)
:
b
(focused)
:
It follows the
neutral point of view
policy
.
Fair representation without bias
:
It is
stable
.
No edit wars etc.
:
It is illustrated by
images
, where possible and appropriate.
a
(images are tagged and non-free images have
fair use rationales
)
:
b
(appropriate use with
suitable captions
)
:
Overall
:
Pass/Fail
:
Really close. In addition to the tags I left, The age of the audio recording concerns me. ON HOLD for up to a week for the minor improvements needed.
Jclemens
(
talk
)
03:55, 4 September 2008 (UTC)
reply
I have addressed your concerns. I hope it now fully meets the criteria. —
scetoaux
(
T
|
C
)
22:19, 5 September 2008 (UTC)
reply
Top Of Page
Home
•
Search
•
Translate
©
CSE