The statue attracted significant criticism in the 2010s due to Ryerson's role in the creation of the
Canadian Indian residential school system. In 2018, a plaque was officially installed on the statue that contextualizes and acknowledged Ryerson's involvement in the history of the Canadian Indian residential school system. The plaque contains the following text:
This plaque serves as a reminder of Ryerson University's commitment to moving forward in the spirit of truth and reconciliation. Egerton Ryerson is widely known for his contributions to Ontario's public educational system. As Chief Superintendent of Education, Ryerson's recommendations were instrumental in the design and implementation of the Indian Residential School System. In 2015, the
Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada concluded that the assimilation amounted to cultural genocide.[6]
Beneath this text are the following two quotations:
"Let us put our minds together to see what kind of lives we can create for our children" – Chief
Sitting Bull
"For the child taken, for the parent left behind" – Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada[7]
In July 2020, three people were arrested for splattering pink paint on the statue – in addition to two others of
John A. Macdonald and
King Edward VII at the
Ontario Legislature – as part of a demand to tear down the monuments.
Black Lives Matter Toronto claimed responsibility for the actions stating that "The action comes after the City of Toronto and the Province of Ontario have failed to take action against police violence against Black people." Three people were each charged with three counts of mischief under $5,000 and conspiracy to commit a summary offence;[8] the charges were dropped the following year.[9]
On June 1, 2021, following the discovery of 215 soil disturbances at the
Kamloops Indian Residential School, the statue was vandalized again, this time with red paint.[10] On June 6, the statue was toppled, decapitated and thrown into
Toronto Harbour; what was then Ryerson University stated that the statue will not be restored or replaced.[11][12] The head of the statue was subsequently placed on a
pike at the
Six Nations of the Grand River near
Caledonia, Ontario.[13]
Booklet Ceremony of Unveiling of the Statue. United Church of Canada Archives.
McDonald, Lynn. “The historical record vindicates Egerton Ryerson.” National Post, 9 September 2021.
Stagg, Ronald and Patrice Dutil. “The Imbecile Attack on Egerton Ryerson.” Dorchester Review (3 June 2021): The Imbecile Attack on Egerton Ryerson – The Dorchester Review
Stagg, Ronald. “Update on the Ryerson Fiasco.” Dorchester Review online 13 May 2022.