In the summer of 2014, he played abroad in the
Canadian Soccer League initially with
Milton SC.[10] He later was transferred to league rivals
Toronto Croatia before the roster freeze on September 1, 2014.[11][10] In his debut season with Toronto, he finished as the club's top goal scorer with 7 goals and secured a postseason berth by finishing second in the First Division.[12][13] In the opening round of the playoffs, he contributed a goal against
SC Waterloo Region which helped the Croats advance to the next round.[14] He would appear in the
CSL Championship final against
York Region Shooters where Toronto was defeated in a penalty shootout.[15]
Menalo would re-sign with Toronto for the 2015 season.[16][17] He assisted the Croats in securing a playoff spot by finishing as runner's up in the league's top division.[18] He would make his second championship final appearance against Waterloo where Toronto successfully secured the title.[19][20]
In 2018, he would sign with the expansion franchise
CSC Mississauga.[21] He returned to Mississauga for the 2019 season.[22] Menalo would assist Mississauga in securing a playoff berth by finishing seventh in the division.[23] Mississauga would be eliminated from the playoff competition in the opening round by
Scarborough SC.[24]
In the summer of 2019, he made a brief return to Toronto Croatia for the 2019
Croatian World Club Championship and was featured in the tournament final against SC Croat San Pedro but lost the series.[25]
^Beganović, A. (14 June 2010).
"Plemići odradili prvi trening" [The nobles completed their first training session]. SPORTSPORT (in Croatian). Retrieved 16 November 2022.
^Bezić Filipović, Branka (8 November 2015).
"Croatia Toronto ponovno kanadski prvak" [Croatia Toronto is the Canadian Champion Again]. HRVATSKA MATICA ISELJENIKA (in Croatian). Retrieved 16 November 2022.
^"Šampion Kanade hara Drugom ligom Jug" [The champion of Canada is ravaging the Second Division South]. Avaz.ba (in Croatian). 2 April 2018. Retrieved 16 November 2022.