Benjamin Reilly, a high school English-teacher in Staten Island, N.Y., witnesses a fight between two students.[5] This brings him back to childhood years of
bullying by Terrence O'Connell, a popular jock he had a crush on at the time.[8] Reilly decides to quit his job, track down his bully and wreak revenge on him.[9] He visits his parents in Indiana, where he also engages in unsafe sex with a
Hispanic man. In Manhattan, he meets with Terrence and they become friends. While on holiday in
Vail, Colorado, he takes an
HIV test - by the end of the novel, he learns he doesn't have AIDS. Terrence breaks up with his girlfriend and slowly admits to being gay, though he won't let Benjamin kiss him. Out of anger, Benjamin pushes Terrence down a mountaintop, sending him off to hospital for several weeks. Terrence proves to be understanding, and they both decide they are now even. Benjamin learns about the circumstances surrounding his sister's death and his brother's runaway streak as a teenager. Finally, Benjamin is invited to Terrence's
same-sex marriage with an investment banker in
Massachusetts.
Characters
Benjamin Reilly, the protagonist. He works as a school-teacher at Tottenville High School. He grew up on
Staten Island.
Benjamin compares Terrence's life in Manhattan to the television series Sex and the City for its overpriced cocktails and ubiquitous investment bankers.